She’s won several awards from the American Pie Council — so I was excited to try her classic key lime pie recipe. Sally’s recipe fell in the “standard” recipe–one of four recipes that included lime juice, condensed milk and egg yolks. Below are the top three key lime pies as rated by my specific group of tasters. Most recipes used all egg yolks (but I included a few recipes to test the inclusion of whole eggs), whipped egg whites, and non-whipped egg whites. I did detect a slightly artificial aftertaste in some bites (and some tasters could instantly taste the difference). I love the creamy, lightly set filling and the contrast of the tart key lime juice against the milkiness of the filling.
A taster commented that the flavor resembled a “margarita,” describing it as sweet and tart without being either acidic or bitter. Slightly more acidity was ultimately perceived in the custard from Epicurious, although the flavors were quite similar overall. The texture of this pie was denser and more set, likening it to a light cheesecake rather than a traditional key lime pie. I would prefer to use the yolks over the whites if I’m going through the effort of separating eggs; I suspect that the whites contributed to a grainier texture in the custard. Since egg yolks are typically incorporated to add richness to a custard — I was very interested in the impact of using whole eggs along with egg whites.
A refreshing contrast to the pie’s creamy filling can be achieved with a light meringue or fresh fruit such as berries. An enjoyable and simple method to enhance both the look and flavor of key lime pie is through decoration. Whipped cream or various toppings should be added to each mini pie, preparing them to serve as individual desserts for guests. Certainly (individual key lime pies make a wonderful choice), particularly for parties or social gatherings.
thc shake : A custard that is thick and creamy, featuring a subtle lime flavor, tastes better when made from scratch.
Nonetheless, this specific recipe for key lime pie that includes sour thc shake cream pairs perfectly with a traditional graham cracker crust. I noticed that the lime flavor in the custard was rather mild (softened by the dairy content), which also helps reduce acidity. We observed that pies using only dairy without eggs (such as those from Divas Can Cook and Tastes Better from Scratch) generally had a milder lime flavor along with a thicker, creamier consistency. The range of variation in this collection of recipes was possibly reduced since I opted for graham cracker crusts across the board (using a Biscoff crust could have been unduly delicious). If you’re searching for the ultimate key lime pie recipe, keep reading to discover the outcomes of my recipe comparison! Every contribution supports us in continuing to develop quality content that motivates delicious meal preparation and informed food choices globally.
Mini Food Processor & Electric Vegetable Chopper by Hamilton Beach.

A graham cracker crust is essential for any key lime pie, and you can enhance it with simple decorative touches. If a light and sophisticated addition to your key lime pie is desired, consider using meringue. By mixing coconut with fruit, your key lime pie can evoke a mini tropical getaway. These fruits introduce a splash of color and a hint of sweetness to offset the tartness of the lime.
Moreover — they are used for producing different marijuana products, such as tinctures, edibles, oils, and topicals.
Although I usually present a chart illustrating the rankings for taste and texture of each item, I’m opting for a different approach this time! Join me in this video as I try to describe all 9 key lime pies, and I will reveal my favorites at the conclusion! As you will observe below (various factors played a role in the textural problems; however), my main takeaway is that using canned condensed milk works just fine!